Harry Potter and the Cursed Child by
J.K. Rowling
My rating:
3 of 5 stars
I have to confess that even though I am a Potterhead through and through and whist I enjoyed "Harry Potter and the cursed child", I did not love it. There are too many irregularities that are not minor plot-holes that prevented me to fully embrace the story.
In the epilogue, I saw a Harry Potter that was comprehensive and good father to his sons, he was understanding and even proud of Albus Severus, named after two Headmasters and one of them Slytherin. I was shocked to learn that Albus felt he was a disgrace because he was a Potter in Slytherin. I believe that the adults were well portrayed but they distantiated themselves from the ones they were 19 years ago and I wonder if we change that lot within time.
Scorpius was my favorite character, he had the characteristics of a nerd (not a geek as stated around three times throughout the play) and to be caring and tender, I imagine Astoria Malfoy to be that way and show compassion and love for her son and husband. I understand that she had to die, but it was hard to see Malfoy turned in a single parent.
Now, I think it was a nice idea to work with the notion of "what if", but is my perception that by asking that question, we start the fanfics. I was not expecting a fanfiction work, but a play that continued the line set by the 7 novels of Harry Potter. I was sorry to read about the conflicts between Harry and Albus, they seemed out of place. Likewise, I thought that between Malfoy and Potter there was cordiality, so I was surprised with the measures taken to separate Scorpius and Malfoy.
Other of the reasons why I thought about fanfiction while reading was that the beloved characters such as Snape and much hated Umbridge appeared in a different timeline. It was heartbreaking to read about a reality where Cedric turned into a Death Eather that caused the fall of Potter and the rise of the Dark Lord with all that that implies. But among the heartache, it was lovely that Snape felt love from Potter because he was honored in the person of Albus.
I understand the story was about family bonding, and also about putting family above all, it was quite important for Harry to take the decision of not to interfer in the killing of his parents and watch it all next to his son and wife, but it was also a bit extreme. The ending was lovely, because I believe that Albus finally understood how Harry has come to terms with all the deaths that have happened in his life, and how sorry was he to see Cedric's death. It is not easy to be a Potter, as it is not easy to carry the legacy of our families within, that we can relate and I hope Albus can understand. It is funny how an event can change completely the future, and how fixed points in time are important even when they are painful.
Now, my biggest problem with this (after all the previous rant) is ... DELPHI. I cannot understand how come she to exist and how come Malfoy not knowing about her (being her niece). I mean, I could never see it coming, a daughter of Voldemort and Bellatrix. That sounds impossible, because yes, Bella adored him, but she was a bit crazy and he did not care at all about love. He was the being that could never feel love, that distroyed him, how could he even care enough to have a child?
Where did she grew up? Was she loved or abused? because even with all his childhood, Harry turned out to be perfectly fine, but her? She was so dissonant that even when I was surprised by the plot twist, I could not buy it. She was a deux ex machina to me and cheapened the story. It reminded me a bit of the Joker and Harley Quinn in an abusive relationship where Harley loves the Joker insanely and the Joker only uses her. But he is mad and abusive, Voldemort was evil not mad, that disturbs me and its my major objection to this play.
There were fun bits and nostalgic bits also, but it did not stand up to the legacy of the franchise.
Still, it was entertaining enough for me to award 3 stars.
View all my reviews